Placed a preorder back in April 2024, and money taken but no item received, Atlantic Sentinels, tried the different emails provided on the website and never had a reply from them, even tried phoning b... See more
While we don't verify specific claims because reviewers' opinions are their own, we may label reviews as "Verified" when we can confirm a business interaction took place. Read more
To protect platform integrity, every review on our platform—verified or not—is screened by our 24/7 automated software. This technology is designed to identify and remove content that breaches our guidelines, including reviews that are not based on a genuine experience. We recognise we may not catch everything, and you can flag anything you think we may have missed. Read more
See what reviewers are saying
I don't normally place negative reviews, however this warrants it. Placed order, which was in stock, then it went out of stock some time after order was placed. Despite numerous emails, phone... See more
Had used several years ago with no issue - read on BGG that the website potentially changed hands at some point. Same issues with every one else on here, wish I'd read the other reviews first.... See more
Only 1star as of now, as ordered item in stock 7 Jan 2025 and received nothing at time of writing (25 Jan).No reply to emails or left phone messages!! If the owner is struggling then get others in to... See more
No recent history of asking for reviews
This company hasn't invited customers recently, so reviews may not be representative
How this company uses Trustpilot
See how their reviews and ratings are sourced, scored, and moderated.
Ordered a game listed as 'in stock'…
Ordered a game listed as 'in stock' over a week ago. It has still not arrived. No replies to emails or phone messages.

Reply from Boardgameguru
Gone downhill a lot recently
Used to be good but service has been terrible for about a year now. Games not sent out for literally months, refunds not processed, emails not replied to and just endless messages on website saying "normal service will resume soon" but never does. Owner should sell business to someone who is more capable of running it.

Reply from Boardgameguru
AVOID
Ordered a game 30/3/22. The game never arrived. I have emailed them 3 times since and had no reply. Scam company. I have purchased 100s of games over the years from different retailers and never experienced anything like this. Ive never left a bad review before this one. Trust me avoid these con artists
Poor service and zero communication
The title says it all! Have used the company many times in the past and found the experience very good.... Unfortunately this is not the case now.
Ordered a game a while back as a pre-order, then several weeks ago when I noted it had been in stock I sent an email asking what the status was of my order...No reply. A few weeks later, I tried again, still no reply. Then a few weeks later I sent a written letter asking for progress.... Still no reply and the game is currently listed as in stock!
I am now both frustrated and annoyed, and to put this into context, this is my first ever negative online shop review. I'm doing this reluctantly, but after three attempts at asking for feedback I feel I have been left with little choice. Furthermore, I am concerned another pre-order I have with them won't turn up due to the experience highlighted here.
Unacceptable delays, zero communication
I hate to leave a negative review, especially for a small business, however the customer
service from this company was appalling. Placed an order on 29/03 for a product that noted 2-3 days for dispatch.
After receiving no update or tracking information I emailed them on 11/04 asking for an update - no response.
I emailed again on 20/04 asking again for an update, no reply. Tried calling them twice with also no response.
Eventually received a dispatch email on 5/05, blaming delays on staff illness.
Game arrived on 09/05 taking well over a month since ordered.
Used to be good. Now very poor.
I've used this company for years and the service was usually good.
However I pre-ordered a game in February and it was released (and listed as in stock by the company) a fortnight ago.
I've e-mailed twice to request an update, but neither e-mail was replied to.
From other comments on here "no game, no communications" sees to be an unfortunately regular occurrence.
I feel ripped off.
UPDATE
As you'll see from the response below they then cancelled my order (which I never asked them to do, despite what the reply says).
I'll update if/when I get my refund...
UPDATE 2
I did get my refund.
UPDATE 3
...and Angus sent me a complimentary copy of the game I'd ordered, which was very good of him.

Reply from Boardgameguru
Poor customer service & communication
I purchased a board game, which was listed as in-stock, on February 10.
A week later it had not been dispatched so I emailed to politely ask for an update. No reply.
Four days later I again politely asked for an update. No reply.
Having not heard anything I posted about my experiences on a well-used board game Facebook page, to check if anyone else had recently had issues with ordering from the company. A number of people said they had.
The person who runs the store evidently saw this post and later emailed me. He said the game had "failed to materialise for some reason" and offered me a refund. He provided no explanation for the failure to respond to my two previous emails.
I asked for a refund but six days later I've received no indication that it is being processed. Needless to say, I won't be shopping again.
One of the best independent online board game stores
I have been using BoardGameGuru for years. In this time the ownership has changed from Paul to Angus but the high standard has remained. This is one of the best independent online board game stores out there.
Excellent store
Excellent store. One of the most reliable and friendly
Zero communication
Ordered a game on 27th November due for restock on the 2nd December. The website updated and the date changed to 7-9th December. Although I appreciate stock dates change the lack of communication has been terrible. I’ve not had any email updates about the place of my order and where I’ve tried to email or call there is no response. I’m now hoping some sort of miracle occurs and it turns up before the end of the week before I’m no longer living in the property I’ve set as my shipping address! 0/5 for communication
Perfectly good service
Perfectly good service - ordered a game, it arrived promptly in a thick box with loads of insulation and padding. Would buy from them again.
Fantastic service from Angus and the…
Fantastic service from Angus and the team. Ordered and received Terraforming Mars: Venus Next but it unfortunately had some production issues. A quick email to the company and they had a new copy sent out with no hassle. Would definitely buy again.
Goods not provided
Ordered a game 6 months ago which was now released over 2 months ago. BGG claim the game has never been shipped to Europe yet, which I have confirmed as false after speaking directly with the publisher. Every other major UK retailer also has the game in stock for immediate dispatch. Board Game Guru do not seem to have any intention of ever providing the goods, and as soon as I asked for the order to be cancelled (over 3 weeks ago) and my payment refunded, they immediately stopped responding to my emails. I will be contacting my bank to begin disputing the payment, and as I know the game’s designer he has also ensured that the publisher no longer lists this website as a UK stockist of their products.
Ordered a game Thursday 23rd Sep and…
Ordered a game Thursday 23rd Sep and still hasn’t arrived. Got told it was done via Royal Mail 1st class so should of been here by now. I ordered another game off another website on Saturday 25th and they use Royal Mail and that has arrived already. Tried emailing board games guru and they take an age to get back saying it should be here any day now. Same old crap, first time I have used these guys will not be buying anything ever again from board games guru. Stick to Zatu!!

Reply from Boardgameguru
No communication
Ordered a game at the beginning of September. Game was in stock on the website and stated would be delivered by DPD (Monday-Friday). Emailed the company to request when it will be delivered. Received nothing back. Now when you go on the website it states that the game is out of stock. Still have had no communication when I will receive the game. Very poor service!

Reply from Boardgameguru
When things go bad, they go real bad
When things go bad, they go real bad.
Last year I ordered a game that was listed as in stock when in reality it wasn't in stock. I also ordered a small item together with the game and I was expecting to receive both items at the same time.
Instead I only received the small item and later had to fight with Boardgameguru for 3 months to get the money back for the game that was not in stock and no longer in print.
When I finally got my money back I still had to pay the full shipping (22gbp) for the small item I received.
These people do not take their business seriously.

Reply from Boardgameguru
Great Customer Service
I placed a preorder as a Xmas gift. Due to no fault of the team at Board Game Guru the preorder was delayed long term thanks to the current COVID situation having a knock on with reprint. As the gift would not arrive until well after the Christmas holiday i requested a cancellation and refund. Without fuss and with professionalism my refund was turned around within hours and confirmation received. Great customer service from a great bunch of people.
Brilliant experience
Ordered three games with them recently. Excellent communication. One game was a pre-order and took longer than excepted to come in so they email me and sent the other games in my order separately so I received them quicker. The delivery company they use is fantastic too - text message updates and an hour delivery slot. Overall, couldn't recommend more - great service!
BoardGameGuru has been great
BoardGameGuru has been great, emailed about a game that was expected to be restocked and had a response same-day. Game was posted out the following day and delivered the day after in less than 24hrs. It was well packaged, each game is individually bubble wrapped.
This is my Friendly Local Games Shop
This is my Friendly Local Games Shop
Angus is knowledgable and always very helpful
Great place, great prices
Have been using for years
The Trustpilot Experience
Anyone can write a Trustpilot review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they’ll be displayed as long as an account is active.
We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. Find out how we combat fake reviews.
Learn about Trustpilot’s review process.
Here are 8 tips for writing great reviews.
Verification can help ensure real people are writing the reviews you read on Trustpilot.
Offering incentives for reviews or asking for them selectively can bias the TrustScore, which goes against our guidelines.







