Very hit and miss; lacking managerial oversight
Huttie has been our plumber for some years and until recently has proven most reliable.
So when we noticed that water was running through pipes even at night when everything was switched off, I contacted their office with the confidence that the matter would be speedily investigated and resolved.
It was not.
It took seventeen days and repeated pleas to the office for help in order to get the initial problem addressed; replacement of valves on the water tank. Unfortunately an unsupervised and inexperienced plumber did the work, the valves were not properly fitted and the trainee made no checks to ensure that this was the only problem. That evening we had to switch off the mains water because it was welling up through the kitchen floor. We also switched off the heating as we were not sure where the problem was. The next day I managed to speak to a young man in the office who was very helpful and made sure that the plumber who had changed the valves was booked in to investigate. He attended but was overwhelmed by the task. He spent hours trying to dig up a patch of floor of about 80cms square.. broke a screw driver in the process, was deeply discouraged, went off to try and find a more suitable digging tool. And then once he had located a hole, he really struggled with fixing it. At one point he was considering calling it a day and leaving us with no water over the weekend but fortunately I managed to convince him that this would not be the right thing to do. He eventually managed to attach the new section of pipe needed to fix the leak and left around 6pm, having been with us all day. If he had had mentoring or another plumber had attended with the correct tools and experience, this would have been resolved in a couple of hours. Eleven days later there was another leak from the water tank. The original confident and capable plumber attended and very swiftly diagnosed that the problem was with the original fitting of the valves and also swiftly tightened them.
So we had a long delay followed by four visits and a total of around 12 hours on-site, where one call-out, plus one speedily arranged follow-up of probably at most say six hours would have done the job; the valves needed replacing, the pipe work investigating, a small section of floor dug up in a timely manner and the pipe fixing with confidence. Because the leak was neglected for so long the kitchen flooring is now in a poor state of repair.
I attempted to raise all of these issues with James Huttie the CEO, simply to ask him to provide better supervision to some of the office staff, better mentoring for trainee plumbers and to review the invoice the office had sent which billed us for the hours which were due to lack of oversight of the young plumber. I had no satisfactory answer at all; the CEO singularly failed to provide any review of what had happened and provided no revision of the bill. I do not like owing money so after literally months of trying and failing to get a decent resolution of the matter we paid the full amount, which was extortionate.
The whole experience was extremely stressful and also distressing because of our previously good experiences with the firm. The recent rapid expansion of the business and the lack of willingness on the part of the CEO to manage what is happening means that the service is currently dramatically hit and miss, lacking in managerial oversight .
I have given two stars; one for the decent office staff member and another for the decent experienced plumber. In future we will be using a different firm.
Sincerely,
Karen Rodgers
**************
May 22, 2025
Unprompted review