Masters Of Mystery Reviews 1,058

Great game. Bought it for a dinner party and we had a ton of fun solving the mystery. Super easy to use and navigate. The step by step instructions were easy to follow and the game was challenging and fun to dig into as a group. Would definitely recommend. We did the online version I would like to try the physical game option at some point.

We have purchased two games from this company and one from a different company and the two we purchased from this company was by far the best! Easy to download, instructions are easy to understand and the fact that they can be reused is a plus

We ordered one of the cold case files as a date night and we really enjoyed it. It is fun to go through the clues and try and solve the mystery. I would describe the difficulty as a challenging in a fun way.

I bought it to my birthday, it were almost twenty people. It was really good, the game was detailed and well put together, everybody loved it. I even did a survey to ask my guests that they would like to play it again this year, and the answer was 100% yes.
I received the game almost immediately, it came with videos, photos, very detailed script, characters with detailed descriptions, it was really good.
The game was perfect length, it was easy to use, it was creative. Very well recommended!

It was a fun, easy game where you could work with someone to solve it. It was hard enough to feel as though it were a challenge and well-constructed. I would recommend this to anyone, and I look forward to more in the future.

What a fantastic game and company. We chose the 1920s themed murder mystery for a New Years Eve gathering with friends and it was a huge hit with everyone. The suggestions provided for costumes, food and music helped to make it a really fun evening. Communication was really quick and helped to make the evening go smoothly which was a big help as there were 19 of us playing along in the end. It was great thay you can purchase add ons as our guest numbers increased.
Highly recommend and we cannot wait to play another game soon.

Our first family mystery dinner was a huge success. The characters were fun and easy to get into, the flow of the game was highly intuitive so even newbies could grasp what to do and what was next. It was one of our best events of the holiday season.

What a super cool company! Such a fun birthday party experience with my closest friends and family. Love the variety of themes and it was easy enough to figure out in a day - but next year we want to take a month to learn our characters well! Will be purchasing another for next year!

The game is very easy to understand through the thorough instructions. Also very helpful that you can instantly print out the entire game and each and every character. The characters are quite diverse in personality and backstory, and the themes are wonderful! All in all a very very cool and unique experience for me and all my friends!

John from Masters of Mystery saved the day when I accidentally purchased the wrong version of the game. Quickly responded and gave a refund no questions asked so I could go back and purchase the right version. He da best

What a fun evening! I was a little overwhelmed at first but once I could get my head around the steps of game play it all fell together. The format was easy to download. I ended up printing everything, scripts and invites, even the evidence pictures. It worked for me to have it in hand rather than digital. Even printed out the sheriff script and played both parts. It was all great. You’ll get out of it what you put in. We had costumes and drinks and turned our living room into a saloon.

This was a Christmas gift for my (nearly adult) children, part fun, part bonding. Turned out to be the best family time we've spent together since they discovered Tik Tok! I highly recommend this one for good, old fashioned quality time!

Who MURDERED Grinch? Bought this Dec 2025 for our annual Xmas Eve dinner & games party. My nephew volunteered to read the files and host the party coz m normally in the kitchen to make sure party is going as planned. EVERYONE LOVED playing the game n loved how everyone played their character nicely, except ... we had 3 lil' kids playing by the piano n having their OWN FUN, which I LOVE!! -->> the ONLY complain was, "it distracted the adults from being 100% present"

Recommendation: no young kids as it's an adult-only game!!

The mystery had typos and the medieval font chosen for the scrolls is very hard to read. The mystery involves making the guests decode scrolls using an A-Z cipher key. This is not only tedious, but pointless, as all the scrolls say roughly the same thing (vague warnings of doom) and don't help solve the mystery. The killer can change, but the clues are always the same, ergo the clues are useless. I bought this mystery for a birthday party, and ended up buying one from a different company.

Ordering was easy and the downloads were available immediately (so if you're looking for last-minute entertainment, this is ideal!). Downloading was simple. Most importantly, my daughter and 10 friends loved it - the storyline kept them entertained for hours! And it's great that anyone can be the murderer, meaning you could play again if you so wished, with a different outcome. Great value!

Did a Murder Mystery for a Christmas party. Wanted to change things up a bit and I'm glad we did. Was a blast. Would definitely do it again.

I’ve gotten quite a few games from Masters Of Mystery and have loved all of them! I like that each kit comes with EVERYTHING you need and that I can join in as the host. I also appreciate all the extras on the website that help me plan a party (recipes, links to Amazon for decorations, and playlists)! I will forever be a returning customer.

I can’t say enough good things about John at Masters of Mystery. He helped me with a refund for part of my order and went out of his way to assist when I needed an extra female character added to the game. His response time was incredibly fast, and the whole experience felt effortless and personal.
This was genuinely one of the best customer service experiences I’ve had. Thank you so much, John!

We gathered as a family on Christmas and did the Christmas Murder mystery that evening. We had a blast doing it, and laughed and enjoyed it immensely. The setup was easy and the booklets laid everything out great and easy to follow. Highly recommend it for a gathering.

Lots of options. I also like that you can use the same game multiple times! Very easy to download the game. It has videos and written option to use in the game. We had lots of fun!!!