Mystery Tackle Box Reviews 

So far when I re subscribed I got new lures and stickers. So far so good great job

Great products and variety month to month! Great value!

Worth the money.I will join back in a few months. Loved all the tackle I got.

My son loved this subscription every month! He loved the stickers and filling his tackle box every month and reading the information that came with it! He’s been fishing since he was a toddler and this was a fantastic idea for him for Christmas and he loved it as a pre-teen.

DEFINITELY GET THIS 100% WORTH IT. Perfect for birthday present/ holiday or when you just want an exciting fun and neat mystery Tacklebox for whoever enjoys fishing.best mystery fishing’s boxes out there I get the elite box definitely get your money out of it. It’s pretty fun to get mystery lures and pretty cool colors and realistic colors too i got this swim bait from my first box and I caught a few stripers lots of small mouth.

someone I believe stole my package off my porch and they will replace free of cost, best experience I’ve had with a company

Have you ever wanted to gift a fun item to someone else or better yet yourself?! This is the thing to get! Every item that has ever come in our mystery box has been useful and used! Things I wouldn’t pick off the shelf myself because I’m a creature of habit will come in this box and simply become my new favorite item!

I’ve never regretted my purchase. Always a 10/10.

I do not like and wish to cancel my subscription

Got “micro” lures. A complete waste of money. Some of the lures are Smaller than my thumbnail! I am very disappointed do not waste your money.

This company and its service is almost a scam. I was given this as a gift in JULY. Still haven't recieved 2 of the 3 boxes that were purchased. The Carrier they use won't deliver the packages and the customer support team doesn't do a whole lot to help with the situation. I wouldn't pay them as you won't get your gear. Find an alternative that will actually give you your tackle.

Update*
They have since redeemed the situation. It took me a lot of back and forth emailing but they supplied me with some bass essentials and my remaining gear. Probably wouldn’t get it again but the service to redeem the situation was good.

My son has got really into bass fishing we fish every day. So I decide to order the PRO Bass box figured it would be pretty neat for him to receive each month the first 2 boxes pretty good the newest box not impressed hope the next box is better. We watch a lot of YouTubers who use these boxes and seem they may get catered to possibly to bait more sells only time will tell. We hope not

Oct 17 2025
After writing the review we received a Email from customer server very professional and understanding. They asked how they could improve the box and also what we didn’t like about it. Jeremey was very helpful and fast to respond I have changed to a 5 star hard to find such great customer service

This is the second time I've ordered a gift of Mystery Tackle Box and the recipient loves it! I love the efficiency of how I am emailed when the box is being prepared, again when it's shipped and again when it arrives. Also included is a list of what's in the box; this process could not be more perfect! I will def be ordering again and I always am recommending to friends who need a gift for a fisherman!

Love everything i got and highly recommend any fishermen to get this box well worth it

My husband and I absolutely loved our boxes! We got things that we didn’t need to get! All of our stickers is either on our bass boat or our vehicles! I higher recommend! Just stopping our subscription as our tackle box is full right now! Will probably start back up when trout season starts back up!

I really enjoy the variety that yall put into the box and now when the box comes my kids are trying to pick out a lure before I can even have a chance to look at it myself.

I have been loving the mystery tackle boxes I have been receiving! Good quality products with a lot of variety!

I highly recommend mystery tackle box. I find they send amazing lures.

I purchased 3 months mystery box for his 13th birthday. He loved them

I received the mystery tackle box as a gift for Father’s Day, I fish every weekend and can’t wait to try the new lures out. The boxes have been better each month and I am getting more fish each month. This Saturday I tried the Bucca baby Rat and caught 3 nice small mouth bass in under 1 hour on the River.