Mystery Tackle Box Reviews 

I bought the advent calendar for my son this year because he’s really into fishing and he was disappointed two of the days he opened, had nothing in it. One of them was stickers, and the other one was a thing to register to win money had nothing to do with fishing tackle. Definitely not worth the money. Very disappointed.

Great products and prices. Paid for a year in advance, its awesome

I began with the knowledge of how business works. This was merely a test with benefits. I subscribed to a monthly box for my son, fully expecting that after 3-4 months there would be a switch. From interesting useable products to an attempt to eliminate stock of undesirable products. And this is what happened. 4th month my son just tossed it on our tackle table. Didn't even open it. I opened it and was expectantly disappointed. Lures, worms, and tackle I would not have given a second look at BASS Pro. Even if the products weren't marked up in price to make it seem like we didn't throw our money away, it's pitiful sizes were aimed at catching small bass. Good business of rotating and eliminating stock. But, not so good for a trophy searching angler. To make my point, my son has been given another test. He goes to any lure selling destination. I gave him the same amount of cash. He gets less but targets those lures he has watched or heard the pro's use. But, not the mini versions. He has caught more and learned more, by using hand picked lures. Truth is he stopped using the tackle he was gifted. Sorry guys, I'm not trying to be mean. But, most times, more is NOT better.

Loved it every month new gear aimed at your favorite fish that month and can change fish from month to month

I love it when my mystery box shows up and see what new jigs plastic lures hooks and all sorts of fishing gear that I get to try out for my next season.

Mystery tackle box is amazing honestly I have no complaints they always give you something that you could ACTAULLY fish and have some luck with, but still every once in awhile throw something that looks or moves totally bonkers but looks promising. I wouldn't reccomend any other mystery box subscription!

Everything is always shipped on time sometime early to what it says at first. Love most the lures I've got and got some good fish this year on them

You send good lures to your door so you don't have to go shopping for your next fishing trip

Last November my daughter got me a gift subscription to Mystery Tackle Box. I thought that was pretty cool, but for the past 65 yrs I've been a live bait guy. Why?? Live fish biting on a piece of plastic..... Get real!
Honestly, I didn't have a clue. Then Mystery Tackle Box arrived in my mail box.. Best gift I've ever received!! Where's the Mystery?? Not in the box!
It's like having a fishing buddy in a box that comes to visit every month and brings along a bit of wisdom! You can teach an Ole dog..

Great customer service and great tackle at a great price

I'm fairly new to fishing, but wanted to learn more with my friends. MTB has been an awesome way to find new lures that I like. Without it, I probably wouldn't even try half of the things I've been sent -- but I'm so thankful I have been able to at least try them. It is always a lot of fun to see what the new month's box has inside!

Mystery Tackle Box is an awesome way for you to try out different lures and soft plastics. I have been with them for well over a year and has accumulated so much tackle, that I have to keep purchasing more tackle storage.

Is Like Christmas every month!! Love it!

My wife gave me a year worth of boxes for my birthday the last 2 years. I love it, it’s like my birthday every month. We have given many of these boxes as presents and have told a bunch of others

Absolutely love getting this box monthly. My son just started to really get into fishing this year and getting a box full of new tackle has been a great experience to share with him!

Picked up the 3 month subscription for my daughter nice set of fishing items, I may get another one for my 5 yr old nephew for Christmas next.

I have been getting the Elite Box for awhile and the items have been pretty good for the most part so I would say the value is there. My issue is the inconsistency at which the boxes are sent out. Sometimes I get them in a decent amount of time and others I get them mid month. Here it is the 6th and my box is still being packaged according to my account. So whenever that is done it still needs shipped via snail mail to me. So looks like another mid month delivery. Very disappointing these should show up within the 1st week of the month. So don't get these boxes if you expect a beginning of the month delivery.

Great subscription! Haven't had any issues and love getting new stuff every month, love the variety of stuff and get to try lures I wouldn't normally buy myself. 10/10 would recommend