Sincere Sally Reviews 

I received my ring and was horrified! The “gold” plating looks cheap, brassy, and bright yellow in comparison to my other gold. Have tried to contact the company for weeks with no reply.
Stay away
Very dissatisfied in Toronto,

Item arrived quickly and was exactly as described

I absolutely love this brand, amazing quality and makes me look great!! Also super sweet customer service girl

Great quality beautiful ring

Quick ship. Great price

Pretty quick to ship. The rings is absolutely beautiful. I can’t wait to order different items! The quality is amazing for the price.

Bought the stud earrings for my sisters birthday, best present ever thank you also fast shipping and great customer service

I got the baguette ring for my GF and she absolutely loves easiest gift ever

Thank you Sincere Sally! My ring is stunning. It took 2 weeks for shipping. So classy, elegant, and sparkling. I can't stop looking at it! Absolutely worth the buy. I'm worth it!

I placed my order on 3/30/26 as of today 4/16/26 I have not received my order . When I contact the company I get a reply requesting patience they took my money right away . I feel the company scammed me I will contact my bank today for a full refund . It’s companies like Sincere Sally that makes you not trust ordering products over the internet . There is NOTHING Sincere about Sally it’s fraudulent !

I ordered a Moissanite Baguette ring in rhodium plated 925 silver. It took nearly 3 weeks to arrive in the U.S. That was OK, but what arrived was a Cubic Zirconia with rhodium plated copper. It is not stamped 925 and the "moissanite" did not come with any paperwork. After wearing it a few days the copper is wearing through. I'm disappointed. I vowed to never buy plated copper rings and here we are.

I ordered and paid for a product I have not received. When I reach out all I get is an auto response they will get back to me. It's been almost 3 weeks, very frustrating.

It took about 3 days to arrive I loved my ring, the size was too big and they were very helpful to get me the correct size to me, I’m very happy

Bought earrings for a wedding, they arrived quickly and were so cute!!

I got my ring in 5 days and its beautiful, looks just like the video i saw on social media that made me buy it

Deceiving false advertisement. Too expensive for low quality. Hard to return - to Australia. Dont issue refund.

The shipping status is stuck at "Shipping Label Created, USPS Awaiting Item" for 20 days so far. Customer Service is not helpful. This is a scam! Don't buy.

It took a while to get to me, but it’s a beautiful set.

Sincere Sally has the best quality jewelry that is STUNNING! Not only do they have amazing pieces, but they ship to you quickly and the staff are so lovely and helpful. I cannot recommend them enough!