Medicare Management of WNY Reviews 

186
TrustScore 5 out of 5

4.9

While we don't verify specific claims because reviewers' opinions are their own, we may label reviews as "Verified" when we can confirm a business interaction took place. Read more

To protect platform integrity, every review on our platform—verified or not—is screened by our 24/7 automated software. This technology is designed to identify and remove content that breaches our guidelines, including reviews that are not based on a genuine experience. We recognise we may not catch everything, and you can flag anything you think we may have missed. Read more

See what reviewers are saying

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Andrew and Lyndsey are simply the best possible choice you can make when making your Medicare decisions. It gives me peace of mind knowing they are available all year round for any help we may need. T... See more

Company replied

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Andrew and Lindsay were absolutely fantastic in helping us with our Medicare sign up. They explained everything so we could understand and answered all the questions we had. They were wonderful to w... See more

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

We are so thankful for the help Andrew and Lindsey gave us. We can't imagine trying to navigate Medicare on our own. They are friendly and knowledgeable and made the process easy. We're confident we g... See more

Company replied

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Andrew and Lyndsey are simply the best possible choice you can make when making your Medicare decisions. It gives me peace of mind knowing they are available all year round for any help I may need.... See more

Company replied

Company details

  1. Health Insurance Agency

Written by the company

A veteran owned/operated company, Medicare Management of WNY believes one thing: confidently knowing what to do with Medicare (and when) is THE KEY to avoiding paying late penalties, fees, or fines and since 2015, only our free, 5-star rated and nationally recognized Medicare SmartStart Program™ will show you how. More than 1,150+ WNY'ers widely consider it the most popular and preferred way to get started and signed up for Medicare in Erie County. This program is proven to make your entire process simpler, easier, stress-free and almost effortless. So, if you aren’t sure where to start with Medicare, feeling forced to figure it out alone is no place to be. Let us take away all your stress trying to tackle everything on your own. This proven program includes: (1) In-person strategy session with a Certified Starting Medicare Specialist™ [CSMS], (2) personalized myMedicare SmartPath planning workbook detailing your exact step-by-step timeline and "to-do" list, (3) myMedicare SmartPath Assessment offers accurate answers and advice about your current situation and scenario to directly determine 'IF' you should sign up for Medicare or suspend until later in life, (4) myMedicare SmartPath Audit provides a professional financial analysis between current employer coverage and costs VS Medicare price and out-of-pocket costs, PLUS, in addition to all those really helpful resources, you'll also get (5) private myMedicare SmartID account access to facilitate setting up your single sign-in service with immediate e-application assistance, (6) initial issue of temporary Medicare ID Card, ALONG WITH (7) exclusive use of our Medicare SmartIQ™ Software, which some say is the most sophisticated, specialized software for comparing insurance companies and costs found nowhere else in all of WNY. We will help you to sign up for Medicare Part A + B, sort through the sea of Insurance Companies, and figure out all the fine print of which plan to pick. We have helped residents sign up for Medicare in Erie County, Niagara County, Chautauqua County, Cattaraugus County, Wyoming County, Genesee County, and Orleans County. Our free Medicare SmartStart Program™ can help you avoid IRS tax fines for conflicts with the coordination of coverage between Work Insurance and Medicare, prevent CMS surcharges for incorrect Medicare application paperwork, and even prevent late enrollment penalties for signing up for Medicare after 65. We offer information on: Local, Regional, and National Medicare Plans, Medicare Advantage Plans, as well as Medicare Supplement Plans.


Contact info

4.9

Excellent

TrustScore 5 out of 5

186 reviews

5-star
4-star
3-star
2-star
1-star

No recent history of asking for reviews

This company hasn't invited customers recently, so reviews may not be representative

How this company uses Trustpilot

See how their reviews and ratings are sourced, scored, and moderated.

4.9

All reviews

(186)

14 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review
Companies on Trustpilot aren't allowed to offer incentives or pay to hide reviews. Reviews are the opinions of individual users and not of Trustpilot. Read more

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

A great team !

Andrew&Lyndsey made the entire process understandable and easy. Very streamlined approach, pleasant and informative. Thank you! I My wife and I will recommend you guys to everybody we know that’s approaching 65.
Keep up the friendly, professional work.

January 25, 2025
Unprompted review
Medicare Management of WNY logo

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY

Thanks, Mike! Happy and humbled our free Medicare SmartStart Program™ could make the new confusing and complicated Medicare process...uncomplicated!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Andrew and Lindsey

Andrew and Lindsey, definitely takes the stress out of making sure you have the correct forms and documents in place in a timely matter and based on your medical needs suggesting what medical plans work best for you, And also will be there to help you with any changes you may need along the way ,

December 7, 2024
Unprompted review
Medicare Management of WNY logo

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY

Thanks, Mike! Happy and humbled our free Medicare SmartStart Program™ could help get things done, done right, and done on time taking away the stress of trying to tackle everything all alone, on your own!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Professional analysis of medical plans

I'm amazed how quickly you assimilated my medical data and 'spit out' a well thought out solution to my medical needs for 2025....and the job was completed in under an hour !
Out of curiosity, do you offer tax preparation services ? 👍

December 6, 2024
Unprompted review
Medicare Management of WNY logo

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY

Thanks, Bill (and Dolly)! Happy and humbled our free Medicare SmartStart Program™ and sophisticated Medicare SmartIQ Software could help find you accurate answers and advice quickly to enjoy more and pay less! WIN - WIN!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Great to work with and they review all…

Great to work with and they review all our needs to find the best fit

December 7, 2024
Unprompted review
Medicare Management of WNY logo

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY

Thanks, Sandy! Happy and humbled our free Medicare SmartStart Program™ could help show you better, smarter ways to enjoy more and pay less! WIN-WIN!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Both Andrew and Lyndsey are very well…

Both Andrew and Lyndsey are very well informed and made what can be a very confusing decision easy. I highly recommend them.

December 7, 2024
Unprompted review
Medicare Management of WNY logo

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY

Thanks, Sue! Happy and humbled our free Medicare SmartStart Program™ could help make the complicated, confusing and challenging chore easier and feel effortless!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Job well done!!!

Andrew and Lindsey did a great job. They took the stress out of the yearly health care enrollment. I left feeling confident that we addressed all my questions, medical needs, and got what is best for me. I also appreciate the ability to reach out at any time to get consultation should the need arise.

December 3, 2024
Unprompted review
Medicare Management of WNY logo

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY

Thanks, Mark! Happy and humbled our free Medicare SmartStart Program™ could help you feel more confident and certain with your insurance choice and show you some new ways to get more and pay less! WIN-WIN!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Medicare Decisions made Human

Andrew & Lyndsey take a complex but very important task of selecting your Medicare coverage that is specific to your health care needs and make it Human! They welcomed questions, provided options and listened to my concerns. I highly recommend Medicare Management of WNY.

November 30, 2024
Unprompted review
Medicare Management of WNY logo

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY

Thanks, Cynthia! Happy and humbled our free Medicare SmartStart Program™ could help make the complex, confusing and challenging chore Medicare can be and give you complete confidence in choosing the best coverage for you!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Thank you Andrew & Lyndsey for all your help

Thank you Andrew & Lyndsey for making it much easier to understand something that should not be as difficult as they make it. With your help & knowledge of all the different insurance companies and policies, it was easier for me to make a decision as to which Insurance Co. is the right one for me. I appreciate all the time you spent with me going through all of my medical needs to help me make the right choice.

November 29, 2024
Unprompted review
Medicare Management of WNY logo

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY

Thanks, Marilyn (and Richard)! Happy and humbled our free Medicare SmartStart Program™ could help make the complicated, confusing and challenging chore Medicare can be easier and feel effortless!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Great free service by professionals

Lyndsey is so knowledgeable about all the Plans available, and she is able to answer all our questions in a way we can understand. She is able to navigate all the complex changes of each plan from year to year and helps us decide on the Plan that is best suited to our current needs. This is something we could never do on our own. Andrew and Lyndsey provide us with a great free service and peace of mind.

November 27, 2024
Unprompted review
Medicare Management of WNY logo

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY

Thanks, SoozieQ! Happy and humbled our free Medicare SmartStart Program™ could help provide you complete confidence and peace of mind!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Continual assistance

I found that Andrew and Lyndsey were both exceptionally helpful, not only in my initial determinations, but also when, because of a change in my needs, in making changes in my policy, with little effort by myself. Then, when changes were made for the new year, the ramifications for me were explained in terms that were understandable. They have been excellent counselors. Thanks again.

November 27, 2024
Unprompted review
Medicare Management of WNY logo

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY

Thanks, Richard! Happy and humbled our free Medicare SmartStart Program™ could provide you accurate answers and advice in an easy to understand way, without you having to worry for wonder what to do!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

We were referred to Andrew and Lyndsey…

We were referred to Andrew and Lyndsey about 3 years ago and continue to find their expertise with Medicare plans so very helpful! When a question comes up, they are right there to find an answer! They return calls promptly and are friendly and a pleasure to work with. We will continue to refer Medicare Management to family and friends.

November 26, 2024
Unprompted review
Medicare Management of WNY logo

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY

Thanks, Judy! Happy and humbled our free Medicare SmartStart Program™ was able to assist and continues to be your trusted source in providing you accurate answers and advice, year after year!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Medicare plans

Lindsey and Andrew provided me with the exact type of service that I had long been searching for. Someone to help me gain a much better understanding of the Medicare options available to me in western NY. And to assist me in figuring out which plan(s) best fit my own needs. Also, I really like to be supportive of small businesses where I live. Lindsey and Andrew offer outstanding services!

November 23, 2024
Unprompted review
Medicare Management of WNY logo

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY

Thanks, Helen! Happy and humbled our free Medicare SmartStart Program™ could help you make a better, smarter informed decision and enjoy getting more and paying less! WIN WIN!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Making Insurance Uncomplicated

I am not a person that is proficient in Insurance, they were able to explain everything to me in a down to earth and uncomplicated way. When I left the office, I was confident I was in the best hands available.

November 22, 2024
Unprompted review
Medicare Management of WNY logo

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY

Thanks, Kathryn (and George)! Happy and humbled our free Medicare SmartStart Program™ could help make the confusing and complicated Medicare conversation...uncomplicated and give you the confidence to make a better, more informed decision!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

They were quick

They were quick, through, and patient. They were able to get my husband a great plan. If needed, we will use them again.

November 22, 2024
Unprompted review
Medicare Management of WNY logo

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY

Thanks, Cindy (and Jim)! Happy and humbled our free Medicare SmartStart Program™ could help you make a better, smarter informed decision and enjoy more and pay less!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

At the last minute I couldn't join my…

At the last minute I couldn't join my wife for the meeting with Lyndsey but Lyndsey continued without me and reviewed and offered suggestions for me along with my wife. It was as if I was there and explained items clear enough to my wife for her to pass on to me. Thank you Lyndsey.

November 21, 2024
Unprompted review
Medicare Management of WNY logo

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY

Thanks, Luther! Happy and humbled our free Medicare SmartStart Program™ could help review, research and recommend better, smarter ways for you to enjoy more and pay less!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Wonder woman of Medicare Management

Lyndsay is a super hero when it comes to Medicare management. 2025 season posed many changes and challenges, but she neutralized them all with her knowledge and expertise and a confident smile. My primary medical group left my current insurance and she matched me with an alternate plan that satisfied my needs and saved me money in prescriptions, that is super hero status in my book!

November 19, 2024
Unprompted review
Medicare Management of WNY logo

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY

Thanks, Sue! Happy and humbled our free Medicare SmartStart Program™ could help make the crazy changes and challenges of 2025...simpler and stress-free!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

2025 Review

We had such a nice time talking with Lindsey yesterday.
Your helpful and caring expertise is so reassuring and beneficial to us. You have helped many of our family members and we want to say thank you again for being there answering all our questions and taking care of all the paperwork. It is also special to see your family as they grow.

November 18, 2024
Unprompted review
Medicare Management of WNY logo

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY

Thanks, Molly (and Mick)! Happy and humbled our free Medicare SmartStart Program™ could help give you the confidence in making a more informed decision. Always a pleasure knowing you continue to trust us, year after year, to continue our care for you and your family with managing Medicare for you.

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Thank you Lindsey!

Thank you Lindsey for reviewing our Medicare Insurances for 2025. Even though we did not need to make any changes to our coverage it is nice knowing that you have our best interest in mind and that we reviewed every part of our coverage. What a great peace of mind we have going into 2025. We will continue to recommend your services to everyone we know turning 65!

November 18, 2024
Unprompted review
Medicare Management of WNY logo

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY

Thanks, Linda (and John)! Happy and humbled our free Medicare SmartStart Program™ could help give you the peace of mind in confidently knowing which private insurance plan was best for you!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Always helpful and explain option’s…

Always helpful and explain option’s perfectly without going off on tangents.

November 12, 2024
Unprompted review
Medicare Management of WNY logo

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY

Thanks, Tim! Happy and humbled our free Medicare SmartStart Program™ could help offer clear, concise and accurate answers and advice!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

I met with Andrew and Lyndsey and was…

I met with Andrew and Lyndsey and was very impressed with their knowledge, they make what can be a very complicated and confusing process very easy to understand. They are very professional and helped me select a plan that was best for me.

November 2, 2024
Unprompted review
Medicare Management of WNY logo

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY

Thanks for your 5-star review! Happy and humbled our free Medicare SmartSaver Program™ could help you enjoy more and pay less! Smart shopping means smart savings!

The Trustpilot Experience

Anyone can write a Trustpilot review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they’ll be displayed as long as an account is active.

We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. Find out how we combat fake reviews.

Learn about Trustpilot’s review process.

Here are 8 tips for writing great reviews.

Verification can help ensure real people are writing the reviews you read on Trustpilot.

Offering incentives for reviews or asking for them selectively can bias the TrustScore, which goes against our guidelines.

Take a closer look