ABI Accountants in Farnham, Surrey - Alan Kirby & Sean Bufton - not recommended
We used to use the services of ABI Accountants in Farnham, Surrey for tax advice along with them managing our company and personal accounts. Sadly we were forced to change to a more reputable firm after they pushed us to join a tax avoidance scheme that has now been investigated by HMRC resulting is having to pay huge fees and tax on monies we never even received.
We had asked Alan Kirby the owner of ABI and his colleague Sean Bufton whether we could purchase shares through our company and for ideas to get our tax bill down and in response to this they recommended we used a special film investment scheme as a method of reducing tax liabilities.
We had always made it clear that we were low risk investors and confirmed this in writing to ABI. But we trusted their advice and we joined the film scheme at significant expense. I have subsequently discovered that the scheme they recommended is deemed a 'significant risk' (this is stated on the prospectus which we were never given by ABI Accountants). They simply ignored our attitude to risk. I can only assume this was driven by their desire to get us signed up so they could earn commission.
I had read negative press about film schemes and raised my concerns only to be told that this one was different and not like the schemes I had read about.
The scheme involved the directors receiving a loan which was then passed onto the company, the loan was then repaid by the company to the directors without having to pay tax. In addition the loan amount was offset against corporation tax. Initially we thought it sounded to good to be true and were worried it was a high risk investment. We had always been very clear we didn't want to take risks, this is confirmed in emails and writing directly with ABI Accountants.
When we expressed concerns around the scheme we were repeatedly assured by Alan Kirby and Sean Bufton at ABI Accountants that the scheme was "HMRC approved" and should anything go wrong we would be put in the exact same position as when we joined it. We have emails to confirm this as well as a pile of evidence that prove that much of what they told us was not in fact the truth.
Email from Alan Kirby at ABI Accountants when we expressed reservations about the scheme he recommended states "The strategies are designed to avoid tax and HMRC may question the scheme for this reason but it is a basic principle that to avoid paying taxes is not illegal and if HMRC decide to question a scheme and if after all of the discussions have been had HMRC can disallow the scheme then the benefits are reversed and you are put back in the same position that you would have been in if you had not implemented the strategy." - This is untrue as we have now been taxed on a loan we never had as if it were income, we are most definitely not in the same position we would have been in had we never joined the scheme. In addition we are tens of thousands of pounds out of pocket in interest, legal and accountants fees. Not to mention the stress and worry this has caused.
Another example of ABI attempting to reassure us that the scheme had no risk is in an email from Sean Bufton at ABI Accountants where he stated "There is actually nothing hanging over the company as a debt or anything just purely a interest in a investment in a LLP, you are tied to the agreement I believe for two years and after that you can exit and so the investment or interest in the LLP will disappear" - this was a complete lie as loan charges to the value of over £300k were registered against the company directors personally and the limited company, there was also no option to exit the scheme (whatsoever), once you are in you are in with huge debt charges registered and hanging over you and we were only able to get out after instructing Solicitors to help us and incurring more huge expense.
I have also since discovered that ABI do not appear to be authorised to provide advice on FCA regulated products. They are also obliged to provide a key facts document and prospectus to their clients, we were never given anything like this, it was simply a case of 'sign here and don't worry'.
We believed what we were told as we trusted ABI as a professional firm of accountants who we believed were acting in our best interests (how wrong this was) so we signed the huge binder of legal paperwork to join the scheme. ABI Accountants will no doubt state that we knew what we were getting into. However, the document was hundreds of pages in length, unless you had a degree in contract law and tax schemes you would never understand it, maybe somewhat naive, but we trusted ABI Accountants, believed what they were telling us and signed the documents in good faith.
Fast forward four years and HMRC have deemed the scheme a 'Tax Avoidance Scheme' and demanded we pay tax on loan monies we never had, stating that is was 'disguised renumeration' this amount extends into six-figures (including over £10,000 in interest).
This sum is on top of all the admin, legal and accountants fees we have had to pay to try and resolve the utter mess created by this ill-informed recommendation.
Not to mention the stress and worry it has caused. We made it clear to ABI that we were not interested in taking risks, yet they still decided to suggest and push this scheme to us, knowing we had limited knowledge and were trusting their expertise.
Yes, we were keen to reduce our tax bill, but we were never interested in getting involved in some kind of shady scheme that would result on us being taxed on income we never even received and I never thought a professional accountancy firm in Farnham would allow their clients to get involved in something like this. All we wanted was risk-free, professional advice, we were badly let down.
My personal opinion is that the recommendation made by ABI Accountants was driven mainly by their receiving commission for signing up clients into this scheme, I don't feel they were protecting our best interests or providing unbiased advice. ABI never disclosed to us if they received commission for signing us up to this scheme, I believe they have a professional duty to do this.
Due to the significant sums involved the matter is now in the hands of our Solicitors who will be seeking compensation from ABI for the losses incurred. I am also aware of a number of other ABI clients who were sold into this scheme and I have made contact with them with a view to a group action.
I am also speaking to a PR company and media sources with a view to making more people aware of the dangers of tax avoidance schemes being recommended by uninformed accountants who know very little about what they are getting their clients into.
The matter has also now been reported to Trading Standards and the Financial Services Authority.
I therefore cannot recommend ABI Accountants as I believe they badly let us down and failed to act in our best interests and will continue on my drive recoup compensation and raise awareness.
Should ABI wish to honour their statement that we will be put in the same position as if we had never joined the scheme we are open to their offer of resolution.
March 15, 2019
Unprompted review