This auction house accepts and sells…
This auction house accepts and sells faked items. I buy vintage and antique toys, a field I've been trading in for nearly 40 years. I have experience and knowledge, and recognise fakes when I see them.
On their recent auction they listed a boxed toy attributed to a famous German toy manufacturer, Schuco, a long established company which has produced highly sophisticated and well recognised toys, since the early 1900s.
It was absolutely obvious when I saw this listing that the box was a complete fake, although it was falsified with the name 'Schuco'. The toy inside was completely different to anything that the Schuco Company has ever manufactured, it is, in fact, a modern cheap tin toy manufactured in China.
I wrote to the Elephant auctions, and included a picture of the modern toy which I found on an Oxfam website, with its original box which clearly states that it was made in China.
I suggested that if they value their reputation they should withdraw this toy from their auction.
Not only did they ignore my message, they went on to sell the new toy in its falsified box.
What drew my attention to their auction was an extremely rare toy, which I was willing to pay good money for in spite of the fact that it was not working. However in view of their obviously dubious business practices, I decided that I would not risk bidding on anything on their auction.
It's a shame that there are people in the antique trade who so cynically fake and consign to auction houses items that have no value and which mislead buyers. It's even more shameful that the auction houses accept such items to auction.
It's also a pity that platforms such as Easy Live Auctions and The Saleroom distance and indemnify themselves against any claims, while accepting fees from innocent buyers on their platforms and apps.
December 4, 2022
Unprompted review