They said all the right things to get my property listed with them. I thought that going with the most local agent made sense - that they somehow had more idea of the local market, but I was wrong. Th... See more
While we don't verify specific claims because reviewers' opinions are their own, we may label reviews as "Verified" when we can confirm a business interaction took place. Read more
To protect platform integrity, every review on our platform—verified or not—is screened by our 24/7 automated software. This technology is designed to identify and remove content that breaches our guidelines, including reviews that are not based on a genuine experience. We recognise we may not catch everything, and you can flag anything you think we may have missed. Read more
See what reviewers are saying
We tried to view a particular house twice but may whetter told us that viewing was unavailable. Long story, but we finally viewed on the third attempt and offered full asking price there and then... See more
(Letting) I am a 24 year old and would never recommend these to anyone or my friends. The way me and my partner were dealt with had made me never want to rent again. From feeling bullied in my own hom... See more
From placing Our house on the market to completion we received excellent communication and service from all staff involved at the St Austell branch. We had full support and if we were unable to commu... See more
Company details
Written by the company
Operating from prominent offices in St Austell and Fowey, and with a smaller office in Polruan, it has separate departments for residential sales, professional services, commercial, residential management and letting, Established in mid Cornwall in the 1920's, the company has established an enviable reputation for its professional and efficient service which is reflected in its wide ranging client base of private individuals, local companies, banks, building societies, PLC's, national and multi-national corporations. Small enough to care but large enough to cope, a local company providing a professional personal service with standards you can trust.
Contact info
Bayview House, St Austell Enterprise Park, Carclaze , PL25 4EJ, St Austell, United Kingdom
- 01726 73501
- martinsmith@maywhetter.co.uk
- www.maywhetter.co.uk
Replied to 50% of negative reviews
Typically replies within 24 hours
How this company uses Trustpilot
See how their reviews and ratings are sourced, scored, and moderated.
Unmotivated to sell my property once listing secured
They said all the right things to get my property listed with them. I thought that going with the most local agent made sense - that they somehow had more idea of the local market, but I was wrong. They set a higher price than the other two agents and I was carried along by their confidence. Despite knowing the sale was due to bereavement, that it was already in need of repair and was going to sit empty, they were happy to proceed with an unrealistic price. Once they had it listed their proactivity ceased. There was one viewing initially which yielded no interest and then no more. We started to find that our calls were not returned we always had to call again. Discussions over pricing turned to asking us what we were prepared to drop it to. They wouldn’t give an opinion, presumably because they didn’t want to admit their initial pricing was unrealistic. I’m sure they will excuse this with ‘market volatility’. Meanwhile, the property itself was deteriorating. We finally gave notice to terminate our contract with them at which point a viewing magically materialised. They wouldn’t communicate with me on the day about how it went and kept brushing me off. Eventually they told me the buyer felt the price was too high. No one thought to speak to me regarding negotiating a lower price. There was no for sale sign outside my property either. I feel that it was used as a filler. Maybe you get a better service for higher end properties? Very unimpressed. The property has been sold inside of six months with a different agent. I give one star for releasing me from my contract early.
We had a very disappointing experience…
We had a very disappointing experience with this letting agency. Throughout our tenancy, we reported multiple serious issues with the property—most notably worsening damp and mold—which were repeatedly acknowledged but never properly addressed. Despite being assured several times that repairs were to be scheduled, nothing was ever followed through.
On more than one occasion, we were blatantly misled about when and what work would be carried out. We did our best to manage what was within our responsibility, even going as far as to replace parts of the kitchen at our own cost.
The situation was made even more frustrating by the agency’s attitude. They were often dismissive, and even made false claims that we had refused access to tradespeople—which was absolutely not the case. In reality, we went out of our way to accommodate repair visits that simply never happened.
The lack of professionalism, accountability, and care for tenants’ wellbeing was shocking. I would not recommend this agency to anyone.
*in response to MWG's reply. The reply does not refer to the property in question in this review.. we did not ask to extend the notice period and those works mentioned in the reply were not carried out at the afore mentioned address. We were shocked by the service we received as it didn't align with reviews of the company.

Reply from May Whetter & Grose
A fantastic estate agents, highly recommend
May Whetter and Grose is a fantastic local estate agents. We cannot recommend the St Austell branch highly enough. The initial market appraisal was conducted by Richard who was extremely knowledgeable regarding the local area and very helpful, professional and personable and we immediately felt confident to choose MWG as a result. Communication / feedback regarding viewings was amazing and the whole team were lovely and nothing was ever too much trouble throughout the marketing process. A buyer was found quickly and Sarah the sales progressor was fantastic at keeping things on track, and keeping us updated right through until completion. Overall the whole team are professional, super helpful, always willing to answer queries and solve problems and we are now using them again. Thank you so much. We cannot praise you enough.
Survey
Paul was very thorough during the expection and talked me through the concerns raised before sending the report.
Highly recommend
I gave instruction to sell my property to the sales team in the St Austell branch. Although my house did take some time to sell, this is no reflection on the sales team. Throughly professional throughout, always kept up to date with viewings, feedback post viewing, diligence with queries and chasing up. I would definitely instruct them again and highly recommend.
Absolutely amazing team
Absolutely amazing team. Made selling our home so easy from start to finish, they put 110% in. Wouldn't go anywhere else again.
Wonderful professional Team really went…
Wonderful professional Team really went over and above to accommodate me and family , great coms any issues sorted straight away .many thanks to Julie ,Nathan and Amy , would recommend to anyone looking for a quality rental with great service along side 💯👋
Don't use them....
Terrible company, they keep you waiting when you've put in an offer, play you against other offers.
This has happened twice now.
Not trustworthy at all.
From Start to Finish …
Our four-bedroomed house was put on the market late last year and secured many more viewings and offers than we expected, despite missing the stamp duty exemptions. The staff were very helpful and gave us much needed sound advice particularly in our choice of a buyer. The sale was completed in early January without any "hitches", for which we are extremely grateful to May Whetter's St Austell office.
(Letting) I am a 24 year old and would…
(Letting) I am a 24 year old and would never recommend these to anyone or my friends. The way me and my partner were dealt with had made me never want to rent again. From feeling bullied in my own home and looked down on most the time. We have just had the worst experience. Would never recommend unless you want to be looked down on and they will never be in the wrong! Wish I could give lower than a 1
Excellent Service
Tony, Sarah and the rest of the team were extremely helpful from putting our property on the market till completion. Nothing was too much trouble.
Would highly recommend them.
Efficient and happy to help
I'm an independent Mortgage Adviser and my clients needed this firm to reissue a report they first put together for a previous owner over 15 years.
The process was made incredibly easy an they communicated throughout.
Great firm.
Very helpful and efficient.
Thank you for the service
Thank you for the service. Good comms between yourselves, us and the vendor. Achieved our target completion date and that's all that maters.
Thank you so much for your help and…
Thank you so much for your help and experience in selling our property
Fabulous service
Once again, excellent service from the St Austell office, the entire team are professional, friendly, patient and approachable at all times. Their local knowledge is second to none and I would highly recommend them to anyone
Secured the sale of the property within…
Secured the sale of the property within days of going on the market.
Really friendly bunch!
Very easy to communicate with.
Where do I start?!
Where do I start?!
All the team are incredibly friendly. Polite. And on the ball.
Whatever your enquiry is, they look into it immediately.
Every time I called, I apologised for bothering them, but I was reassured that I could call anytime I wanted. Very understanding.
Along with our awsome solicitor, we managed to go from having our offer accepted to collecting the keys in 8 weeks to the day!!! That's amazing!
They totally understood our circumstances & done all they could to move things along for us & gave great advice.
This is the second property I have bought from M,W&G . First 15 years ago. Still the same great service.
I would highly recommend this company. They tick all the boxes. I cannot praise them enough. Also 10 out of 10 for the covid safety precautions they took!
Well done to all you lovely people
Thank you very much
: )
The Trustpilot Experience
Anyone can write a Trustpilot review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they’ll be displayed as long as an account is active.
Companies can ask for reviews via automatic invitations. Labeled Verified, they’re about genuine experiences.
Learn more about other kinds of reviews.
We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. Find out how we combat fake reviews.
Learn about Trustpilot’s review process.
Here are 8 tips for writing great reviews.
Verification can help ensure real people are writing the reviews you read on Trustpilot.
Offering incentives for reviews or asking for them selectively can bias the TrustScore, which goes against our guidelines.







