Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl) Reviews 

85
•
TrustScore 2.5 out of 5

2.3

While we don't verify specific claims because reviewers' opinions are their own, we may label reviews as "Verified" when we can confirm a business interaction took place. Read more

To protect platform integrity, every review on our platform—verified or not—is screened by our 24/7 automated software. This technology is designed to identify and remove content that breaches our guidelines, including reviews that are not based on a genuine experience. We recognise we may not catch everything, and you can flag anything you think we may have missed. Read more

See what reviewers are saying

Rated 1 out of 5 stars

We consider that we were the victims of a dishonest offer when chartering the Little Mokoro, managed by Sailing Sicily, via yachting.com from 27 June 2026 to 11 July 2026. The boat exhibited sign... See more

Company replied

Rated 1 out of 5 stars

In September 2026, I rented the sailboat Alice in Cannigione, Sardinia. The boat was handed over to me in a horrible state. The bilges were full of water, which the bilge pump would not remove. The wi... See more

Company replied

Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Extremely disappointing experience. Terrible boat condition, poor maintenance, unhygienic standards and completely unprofessional service. The mainsail was defective and could not be operated prop... See more

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

We made a one-week-trip starting from Marina Scarlino and discovered the Elba region. It was easy to get safe mooring places outside the main season. We sailed Roberta, a 46 feet Bavaria yacht, which... See more

Company replied

Company details

  1. Boat Rental Service

Written by the company

Dream it, Sail it! Sailingsicily, è una azienda leader nel noleggio e gestione di barche a vela e catamarani in Italia, che nasce a Palermo nel 2003 dall’esperienza e dall’amore per il mare e per la vela dei fratelli Paolo e Marco di Trapani. Scegliere Sailingsicily significa affidarsi ad un team di 25 persone che con onestà professionalità e competenza sono pronte ad assistere h24 i propri clienti e soddisfare le loro esigenze. L’azienda oggi conta 7 basi nei più belli ed esclusivi Marina delle coste italiane (Sicilia, Costiera Amalfitana, Sardegna, Toscana ed Emilia Romagna) ed una flotta esclusiva e sempre aggiornata con più di 65 barche a vela e catamarani dei più importanti cantieri navali come Jeanneau, Bavaria, Beneteau, Bali, Fountaine Pajot.


Contact info

2.3

Poor

TrustScore 2.5 out of 5

85 reviews

5-star
4-star
3-star
2-star
1-star

No recent history of asking for reviews

This company hasn't invited customers recently, so reviews may not be representative

Replied to 66% of negative reviews

Typically replies within 48 hours

How this company uses Trustpilot

See how their reviews and ratings are sourced, scored, and moderated.

2.3

All reviews

(85)

4 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review
Companies on Trustpilot aren't allowed to offer incentives or pay to hide reviews. Reviews are the opinions of individual users and not of Trustpilot. Read more

Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Extremely disappointing experience

Extremely disappointing experience. Terrible boat condition, poor maintenance, unhygienic standards and completely unprofessional service. The mainsail was defective and could not be operated properly throughout the charter. The boat had an unbearable sewage smell, making life on board extremely unpleasant. Even worse, another boat from the same charter company moored beside us had similar serious technical problems.

Staff were unhelpful, communication was appalling, and technical issues were simply ignored. Clearly, proper maintenance and customer satisfaction are not priorities.

Absolutely unacceptable standards for a yacht charter company. We would never charter with them again. Avoid this company!

September 27, 2026
Unprompted review
Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Worst boat renting experience in forty years of chartering

We consider that we were the victims of a dishonest offer when chartering the Little Mokoro, managed by Sailing Sicily, via yachting.com from 27 June 2026 to 11 July 2026.
The boat exhibited significant shortcomings in terms of both maintenance and safety.
In forty years of chartering boats, we have never been let a sailing boat in such a condition.
We also consider that we were misled by the use of the term ‘Comfort Pack’, which was compulsory and cost a totally unjustifiable €750.
We cannot understand how a charter company dares to rent out a boat in this condition, nor how an online broker would list boats from this company.

July 11, 2026
Unprompted review
Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl) logo

Reply from Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl)

Dear Mr Gielis,

We are sorry to read your review, particularly considering the extensive correspondence we have already exchanged regarding your charter.

We would like to clarify a few important facts for the benefit of future customers.

First, the mandatory Starter Pack costs €730, not €750, and includes final cleaning, outboard engine rental for two weeks, bed linen and two gas cylinders. These services and their costs are clearly specified in the booking conditions.

Regarding the maintenance issues you reported, we have already addressed each point individually in our previous correspondence. Some observations concerned minor wear and tear, while others could have been resolved immediately had they been reported during check-in. Our base staff also provided you with outboard fuel free of charge as a gesture of goodwill.

However, your review omits a significant aspect of this charter: the bathing platform suffered substantial damage following an impact caused by the wake of a passing vessel while the yacht was moored at Stromboli.

We have disputed your claim that this damage resulted from a pre-existing defect. Based on the information available to us, we maintain that the damage was not attributable to inadequate maintenance by our company.

While we respect every customer's right to express dissatisfaction, we believe that a fair review should also reflect the relevant circumstances of the charter, particularly when a dispute concerning damage to the vessel has arisen.

We remain committed to maintaining our fleet, addressing genuine technical issues and providing transparent information to our customers.

Kind regards,

Sailing Sicily Management

Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Horrible experience

In September 2026, I rented the sailboat Alice in Cannigione, Sardinia. The boat was handed over to me in a horrible state. The bilges were full of water, which the bilge pump would not remove. The wind instruments were broken. The swimming platform was damaged from hitting the dock and would not close properly. The anchor light and steaming light were broken. The VHF radio did not have DSC enabled. Not a single electric socket was functional, even when the boat was connected to ground power. We were not even given enough blankets for all crew - just one blanket per cabin. Never again. I filed a formal complaint asking for a refund of 25%, which Sailong Sicily rejected. Two other boats of Sailing Sicily had such serious problems that they were unable to leave the marina on day 1, so I suspect the problems are systemic, not a coincidence.

September 19, 2026
Unprompted review
Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl) logo

Reply from Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl)

Dear Mr. Krycha,

We are sorry that your experience aboard Alice did not meet your expectations. However, we believe that your review does not provide a complete and accurate picture of the circumstances.

As you correctly mentioned in your formal complaint, we were in direct contact during check-in and our base manager, Paolo, assisted you with the issues reported.

Regarding the water in the bilges, this was residual water that should have been removed during cleaning. We acknowledge this oversight. Paolo personally removed the remaining water on Sunday morning. This was not evidence of a malfunctioning bilge pump, as the water was located in compartments separate from the one containing the pump.

The wind instruments were restored to operation with a system restart during check-in. Regarding the navigation lights, our base manager confirms that they were working, and the check-out checklist also records them as operational.

The electrical sockets could be used by switching off the water heater, as explained by our staff. The swimming platform, although slightly bent, remained usable.

We acknowledge that certain minor items required attention, but these should be distinguished from defects that would make a vessel unseaworthy.

Regarding the VHF, the absence of DSC functionality is not, in itself, evidence that the vessel was unfit for charter.

We also wish to clarify that Corsica is outside our recommended sailing area for logistical assistance reasons, not because of any limitation affecting the vessel's seaworthiness.

Finally, we strongly disagree with your suggestion that our fleet suffers from systemic problems. Your reference to two other vessels concerns separate charter experiences and cannot reasonably be used to draw general conclusions about our company's maintenance standards.

We take customer feedback seriously and continuously invest in maintaining our fleet. While we regret that some aspects of your charter were disappointing, we do not agree with the overall portrayal of the vessel or our company in your review.

Kind regards,

Sailing Sicily

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Everything was perfect

Easy and uncomplicated booking, quick and very friendly communication and very friendly staff. Also, they had a good recommendation for a skipper. Overall, a great experience.

August 29, 2026
Unprompted review
Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Title: Unsafe Boat, Unfair Practices – A Cautionary Tale


Our charter with Sailing Sicily was one of the worst experiences we have ever had at sea. The boat delivered had serious and dangerous technical issues: the main engine was unreliable and the furling system failed during the trip. These are not minor inconveniences — they are safety hazards that should have been addressed before handing over the vessel.

Assistance was slow and dismissive, leaving us to manage stressful and unsafe situations on our own. Instead of taking responsibility, the company tried to pressure me into signing an unfair waiver in order to release my security deposit. When I refused to sign, they unjustifiably withheld €1,379 from my deposit without any proper documentation or legal basis.

This behaviour is unprofessional, unethical, and shows complete disregard for customer safety and rights. Sailing Sicily not only failed to deliver a seaworthy vessel, but also attempted to shift the consequences of their negligence onto their customers.

For anyone considering a charter with this company: think twice. There are many other operators who value safety, transparency, and fairness — Sailing Sicily is not one of them.

July 19, 2025
Unprompted review
Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl) logo

Reply from Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl)

As often happens, unfortunately, the narrative presented does not represent the objective reality of the facts.

The boat presented no safety issues: it was rented only with positive feedback in the weeks before and after.

We cannot comment on the captain's technical expertise (although this should always be taken into account in rental agreements).

The boat presented no safety issues. The "broken" engine not only restarted without problems, but when it was inspected the next morning by a mechanic, he confirmed that no repairs were required.

On the other hand, the boat was delivered to the customer sooner than contractually agreed.

The only real inconvenience the customer experienced (for which I would not rule out holding him responsible) concerned a zipper on the boat's awning that broke AFTER its first sailing due to the customer's constant attempts to tighten it.

Furthermore, following both the navigation code and common sense, any responsible captain would never use a vessel with serious maintenance problems for two weeks, putting himself and the crew at risk. In fact, the client's requests immediately appeared unfounded and specious.

Despite this, in an effort to maintain a business relationship with the client and protect the relationship with the agency that procured him, the offer was made not to charge for the cost of garbage bags left on board (ignoring the general cleanliness of the vessel) and the cost of an outboard motor broken by the client.

In addition to all of the above, a €200 voucher for future vacations was offered.

The value of the offer exceeded €1,500.

Before carrying out this commercial transaction, we were asked to sign a release that protected both parties from any future claims (us for the customer's claims and him for the damages caused).

Since the customer refused to accept this and expressed his willingness to pursue legal action, we proceeded with the standard procedure, withholding the deposit as compensation for the damages he caused.

I emphasize that to date, the casing of the engine he broke is still available for analysis and collection.

From the beginning, we demonstrated complete openness to closing the matter quickly and fairly, sacrificing our right to reimbursement for damages, but we found ourselves forced by the customer's decisions to proceed as described.

Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Title: Neglected Boat and No Support – Holiday Ruined

I joined a sailing holiday expecting a relaxing trip, but from the very first day the boat was in terrible condition.

The windlass worked only occasionally — and there was no spare remote. It was finally repaired on July 13, but by then we had already lost valuable time. The sprayhood was torn and unusable, still under repair as of July 14. The forward hatch wouldn’t close. The mainsail couldn’t fully retract into the mast. The bathroom door kept swinging open. The bedroom door handle came off in my hand. The stove gimbal was tilted and couldn’t be locked. The cockpit table wouldn’t stay open.

On top of that, there were no towels, the second set of bed linen was missing, and there were only two glasses on board.

Because of all these problems, we couldn’t even leave port for days. The base manager, Pietro, was never reachable. I left him a WhatsApp message on July 12 and never got a reply. The local contact in Cannigione, Matias, told me bluntly: “If you don’t like the boat, you can get off,” in front of other staff.

I had planned to sail to Corsica, but because of the ongoing repairs during my charter week, I couldn’t make the trip. This cost me money for ferry tickets, park fees for La Maddalena, and all my travel arrangements.

The only positive note was Paolo from the staff, who kept trying to fix things, but by the time he finished, it was already midday on July 14.

This was a deeply disappointing experience, and it completely ruined my holiday.

Date of experience: 12–14 July

July 12, 2025
Unprompted review
Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl) logo

Reply from Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl)

As often happens, unfortunately, the narrative presented does not represent the objective reality of the facts.

The boat presented no safety issues: it was rented only with positive feedback in the weeks before and after.

We cannot comment on the captain's technical expertise (although this should always be taken into account in rental agreements).

The boat presented no safety issues. The "broken" engine not only restarted without problems, but when it was inspected the next morning by a mechanic, he confirmed that no repairs were required.

On the other hand, the boat was delivered to the customer sooner than contractually agreed.

The only real inconvenience the customer experienced (for which I would not rule out holding him responsible) concerned a zipper on the boat's awning that broke AFTER its first sailing due to the customer's constant attempts to tighten it.

Furthermore, following both the navigation code and common sense, any responsible captain would never use a vessel with serious maintenance problems for two weeks, putting himself and the crew at risk. In fact, the client's requests immediately appeared unfounded and specious.

Despite this, in an effort to maintain a business relationship with the client and protect the relationship with the agency that procured him, the offer was made not to charge for the cost of garbage bags left on board (ignoring the general cleanliness of the vessel) and the cost of an outboard motor broken by the client.

In addition to all of the above, a €200 voucher for future vacations was offered.

The value of the offer exceeded €1,500.

Before carrying out this commercial transaction, we were asked to sign a release that protected both parties from any future claims (us for the customer's claims and him for the damages caused).

Since the customer refused to accept this and expressed his willingness to pursue legal action, we proceeded with the standard procedure, withholding the deposit as compensation for the damages he caused.

I emphasize that to date, the casing of the engine he broke is still available for analysis and collection.

From the beginning, we demonstrated complete openness to closing the matter quickly and fairly, sacrificing our right to reimbursement for damages, but we found ourselves forced by the customer's decisions to proceed as described.

Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Worst chartering company in Europe

Worst chartering company in Europe. When boats breakdown they don't take any resoponsibility whatsoever. Pick a DIFFERENT charterer and enjoy your vacation.

September 10, 2024
Unprompted review
Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl) logo

Reply from Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl)

Hi Timo,
it's disappointing to see your review, especially considering that you were the one who caused the damage to the boat.
I believe it's only fair to write here for those who will read your review, in order to tell the truth and not just your version influenced by the fact that you had to pay for the damage (even though only partially, as we decided to cover half of it ourselves).

The plain truth is that during navigation, several days after you had rented the boat, you broke the gearbox (probably by hitting something or due to improper use — although not being on board with you, I cannot know exactly what happened).
You immediately received assistance, and we also gave you and/or your appointed surveyor the opportunity to inspect the damaged part.
Meanwhile, the boat was blocked for months, causing a loss far greater than the cost of the repair itself.
Nevertheless, understanding that it was an accident, we made a commercial gesture and, by mutual agreement, retained only half of the security deposit.

Now, after months, we are reading your review on Trustpilot, most likely written out of anger.
We are saddened that instead of appreciating the gesture, you have chosen to express resentment.

Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Horrible action after being dismasted

In September 2024, we rented a boat (Oceanis 45, from 2019) from SailingSicily. In the middle of our voyage between Elba and the island of Capraia, the main mast broke, and the entire sails collapsed into the water. At that time, the wind was blowing at BF 4-5. Fortunately, no one was hurt, and after agreeing with the owners, we managed to return to the marina Di Scarlino. It was a long and challenging journey because the sailboat was difficult to control, but we made it. We wrote a report on the accident - we were absolutely not sailing beyond the boat’s limits or the skipper’s qualifications. What followed was a terrible disappointment. Sailing Sicily is still withholding the EUR 3,000 deposit, even though we did nothing wrong and it was not our fault. Communication is going nowhere, we don’t even have an insurance report. After two months, there is still nothing, absolutely nothing. Totally unprofessional behavior. Absolutely no explanation as to why the deposit is still being withheld.

Get yourselves together and take action!
You are using someone else’s money without any justification!

September 11, 2024
Unprompted review
Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl) logo

Reply from Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl)

Dear Josef,

i'm sorry to read your words here.

You tried to blame the problem due to corrosion or construction defects, but no things like that were present in the mast.

After all, the vessel had been operating for years, without any issues until your week in wich weather was so bad the coast guard was unable to go out for the rescue.

That said, responsibility for the incident lies entirely with the lessee, who evidently mishandled the boat and sails in dangerous weather conditions.

I understand the frustration to have to pay for a damage that you don't want to accept is your fault but there is nothing we can do in front of the facts.

Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Terrible experience at Marsala Marina - Avoid at all costs!

We rented a Bali 4.6 catamaran named "Freezer" in Marsala, Sicily, through Sailingsicily for a family and friends vacation. Unfortunately, the experience was extremely disappointing. Upon arrival, we found the marina in very poor condition, which immediately soured our stay. The staff on site were cold and unfriendly, not even offering a simple greeting – an entirely unacceptable welcome.

The boat itself was in terrible shape: mold, dirt everywhere, both inside and out. The staff tried to blame the weather for this condition, which is simply unacceptable for a rental of this caliber.

During our trip, several damages occurred, and although we were not responsible, the owner is now trying to charge us for them. This is nothing short of theft. Additionally, we lost a propeller during a maneuver, which made our navigation much more difficult.

There was absolutely no concern for our safety: they never bothered to check if we were okay or safe after the incident. Instead, they went as far as to tell us they would take the deposit without even investigating the cause of the issue!

As if that wasn’t enough, the boat’s dinghy was in terrible condition: punctured, scratched, with a broken handle, and more. Despite this, they are charging us for scratches that were already there when we arrived, insisting it was our responsibility to photograph them. Moreover, the paddleboard we rented as an extra was also unusable for the same reasons. We spent more time dealing with these issues than enjoying our vacation.

I strongly advise against renting this boat or using the services of this marina. Avoid it if you don’t want your vacation ruined!

August 17, 2024
Unprompted review
Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl) logo

Reply from Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl)

Dear Gatien,

I understand that when a client casuses a damage he's angry since he have to pay.

Truth is really different.

From the start of your rental you bringed a dog without advising us before and had issue with the extra cleaning costs; you also wanted for free a change of bed line/towels that you did not order and then you lost a propeller. It is normal that you have to pay for a damage caused by you.

You never were in danger. You always had assistance and the second propeller fully functioning so i'd say that this review is just dictated by the anger for the lost amount for the damages.

Rated 4 out of 5 stars

Overall good

The Yacht Orchidea was in useable shape, sails engine worked properly. Staff of Sailing Sicilly was friendly and helpful.

June 29, 2024
Unprompted review
Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl) logo

Reply from Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl)

Thank you so much for the review!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Beautiful Sailing - Elba / Corsica

Beautiful sailing week nearby Elba and Corsica⛵️👍

Boat was perfectly prepared.
Very friendly service from Marina Di Scarlino 👍

July 6, 2024
Unprompted review
Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl) logo

Reply from Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl)

Thank you so much for the review!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Excellent experience

Very customer-oriented, easy on-line procedures for check-in and check-out, competent and kind on-site personnel in the charter base

June 15, 2024
Unprompted review
Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl) logo

Reply from Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl)

Thanks so much for the review!

Thanks to online check-in, our customers who arrive at the base only have to think about boarding and enjoying their holidays!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Bavaria 46 in Marina di Scarlino

I chartered a Bavaria 46 in Marina di Scarlino. Excellent service, check in and check out was relaxed and professional. During the week we had trouble with the electrical bathing platform and the charter company took a lot of time to help us via phone to fix it. Sails, engine and batteries in very good condition. The boat was 6 years old and very well maintained.

June 8, 2024
Unprompted review
Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl) logo

Reply from Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl)


Thanks so much for the review!

Maintenance is one of the aspects to which we dedicate the most time and attention. We are happy that the service was to your liking and we hope to have you back with us soon!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Marina Scarlino

We made a one-week-trip starting from Marina Scarlino and discovered the Elba region. It was easy to get safe mooring places outside the main season. We sailed Roberta, a 46 feet Bavaria yacht, which was in a very good condition. The Sailing Sicily staff was kind and helpful. Definitely recommendable!

May 18, 2024
Unprompted review
Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl) logo

Reply from Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl)

Grazie mille della recensione!

Speriamo di riavervi presto con noi in una della nostre basi per replicare l'esperienza.

A presto!

Rated 4 out of 5 stars

Our boat was technically in good shape

Our boat was technically in good shape. Due to the age (2017) of the boat it showed a lot of scratches. Sailing wise it was a good boat with e.g. a new jib sail. The service was good, with personal attention when needed.

May 11, 2024
Unprompted review
Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl) logo

Reply from Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl)


Thanks so much for the review!

We pay particular attention to the state of maintenance of older boats and do our utmost to ensure that the experience is always of a high level!

See you soon!

Rated 4 out of 5 stars

Super Yacht

Very good boat, 4stars because there were only 2 safety belts on board and few dishes. Good service by the team.

May 17, 2024
Unprompted review
Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl) logo

Reply from Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl)

Thanks so much for the review!

We pay particular attention to the state of maintenance of older boats and do our utmost to ensure that the experience is always of a high level!

If we had known you needed more belts or kitchen equipment we would have brought it immediately.

See you soon!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Great service

Great service , highly recommend!!

August 26, 2023
Unprompted review
Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl) logo

Reply from Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl)

Thank you so much for the review!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Customer Care

Had a great time sailing the Aeolian Islands for two weeks with Sailingsicily. The service was friendly and professional, the boat in a good condition. Handover IN/OUT extremely professional and fair.

Most appreciated was the handling of a complaint we had with missing SUP. That was resolved afterwards in a very attentive and caring manner. Things happen but good solutions depend on the mindset of people. Thumbs up for the team of Sailingsicily 👍🏻👍🏻

July 14, 2023
Unprompted review
Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl) logo

Reply from Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl)

Thank you so much for the review!

It is our duty to fix problems when they arise!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Excelent service

Excelent service, we get yacht at 2pm with no problems, personal was very frendly. Everything was Ok. Thank you.

June 9, 2023
Unprompted review
Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl) logo

Reply from Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl)

Thank you so much for the review!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Everything was fine

Everything was fine, helpful, fair and kind, no problems with the yacht, it was in a good technical condition and clean, we were very satisfied

May 12, 2023
Unprompted review
Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl) logo

Reply from Sailingsicily (Sailing race Service srl)

Thank you so much for the review!

The Trustpilot Experience

Anyone can write a Trustpilot review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they’ll be displayed as long as an account is active.

We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. Find out how we combat fake reviews.

Learn about Trustpilot’s review process.

Here are 8 tips for writing great reviews.

Verification can help ensure real people are writing the reviews you read on Trustpilot.

Offering incentives for reviews or asking for them selectively can bias the TrustScore, which goes against our guidelines.

Take a closer look